The American Transportation Research Institute’s (ATRI’s) latest report reveals a snapshot of the transportation industry’s biggest hurdles and economic pressures. The findings call attention to a persistent freight recession, soaring operational costs, and an ever-shifting regulatory environment.
In this blog, we dive into ATRI’s report to see how transportation issues are shaping the day-to-day realities of fleet managers, drivers, and the industry as a whole.
Economic pressures and the freight recession
For the second consecutive year, the economy tops the list of concerns in the ATRI survey,
reflecting the broader challenges tied to a freight recession that began in 2022. While the overall U.S. economy saw growth, the trucking sector has lagged, with lower freight rates and decreased tonnage pushing many carriers out of business.
The primary drivers of the freight recession include a slowdown in consumer demand, tepid retail sales, and flat manufacturing outputs, even as the broader economy shows resilience with lowering inflation and higher GDP. Margins are being squeezed by rising costs, including a 22% increase in operational expenses over the past two years.
Truck parking shortages and infrastructure deficiencies
One of the most persistent issues ATRI highlighted is the lack of available parking. This topic remains the second-highest concern among respondents, and for drivers, it’s the top issue. Despite recent federal investments of more than $292 million in parking projects, as well as state-level and private initiatives, the lack of parking continues to hamper productivity and compromise driver safety.
As drivers struggle to find parking from day to day, they’re often left to park in unsafe locations. Local regulations restricting parking, especially in urban areas, compound the issue, leading to inefficiency and delays. Advocates are pushing for dedicated federal funding to improve parking infrastructure, which would help ease one of the most critical pain points for the industry.
Legal and insurance challenges: The impact of nuclear verdicts
Lawsuit abuse has risen to the third-most critical issue in the industry, a reflection of the growing burden of excessive litigation. The term “nuclear verdicts” refers to massive settlements or judgments awarded by juries, with some awards exceeding $160 million, as seen in the recent case involving Daimler.
The surge in legal costs is directly linked to higher insurance premiums. Premiums have jumped by 12.5% since 2023, further straining carriers’ finances. According to the ATRI study, crash numbers have decreased. Nonetheless, with the risks of potential litigation, insurance costs continue to rise.
Battery electric vehicles: High costs, uncertain returns
For commercial fleets, the push toward electrification has grown in urgency, with battery-electric vehicles ranking as the sixth-highest concern in ATRI’s 2024 survey. Regulatory mandates, particularly in states like California, have set ambitious timelines for transitioning to zero-emission vehicles. While the industry supports reducing its environmental impact, the financial burden associated with BEV adoption is a major obstacle. ATRI estimates that transitioning to BEVs will require more than $1 trillion in infrastructure investment and vehicle purchase costs.
The concerns go beyond financial costs. Industry leaders also worry about the lack of charging infrastructure, the heavier weight of BEVs impacting roadways, and the potential safety risks in case of accidents involving electric trucks. Challenges like these highlight the need for a more gradual transition, one that takes into account the significant logistical and financial barriers.
Driver-related issues: Compensation, detention, and the shrinking workforce
Driver compensation and shortages are constant issues for the industry. While driver wages have increased over the past several years, smaller fleets have struggled to keep up with the rising costs of operations, particularly as freight rates fall. ATRI notes that addressing driver pay is crucial, especially compensating for time spent during detention at customer facilities, which was responsible for over $11billion in lost revenue in 2023 alone.
Detention time affects driver earnings and poses safety risks. Drivers who get delayed are more likely to speed to make up for lost time, increasing the risk of accidents. Addressing these issues can help improve driver satisfaction and safety outcomes.
While the driver shortage has temporarily eased due to the freight recession, the long-term outlook is concerning. The trucking industry is still short tens of thousands of drivers, and as the economy picks up, the gap is expected to widen again as more seasoned drivers retire. The industry is exploring new pathways to attract a younger and more diverse workforce, including outreach to military veterans and underrepresented populations.
CSA: Still a point of frustration despite likely revisions
FMCSA’s Compliance, Safety, and Accountability (CSA) program re-entered the top 10 after falling off in 2023. Despite being in operation for more than a decade, the program raises concerns among motor carriers, particularly regarding the accuracy of safety scoring methods and the impact of state-level enforcement disparities on those scores.
Stakeholders are pushing for further updates to improve transparency and fairness in how carrier performance is calculated, noting that inconsistencies across states can unfairly penalize certain fleets. In 2023, FMCSA proposed potential revisions to the program that would address many of the concerns; however, a firm date for changes has yet to be published.
Driver distraction: An ongoing safety hazard
Driver distraction remains a critical safety issue, ranking tenth in ATRI’s survey. According to ATRI’s 2024 Critical Issues Report, in 2022, across all vehicle types, more than 3,300 people died in distraction-related crashes, and many of them involved cell phone use. Industry leaders and safety advocates are calling for stricter penalties and tougher enforcement of anti-distraction laws. Reducing distraction for drivers is essential to improving road safety and lowering accident rates.
Conclusion
ATRI’s 2024 Top Industry Issues Report paints a picture of an industry grappling with economic
headwinds, regulatory pressures, and operational challenges. While the industry remains essential to the U.S. economy, the ability of carriers to adapt to these challenges will impact the future resilience of many transportation companies. From addressing the freight recession to preparing for an electrified future, fleets will have to navigate a complex landscape of issues that will shape its trajectory for years to come.
Curious about what 2025 holds for the transportation industry? 🚛 Check out Motive’s new Holiday Outlook Report for an exclusive look at what to expect during the high stakes holiday season and beyond.
