On-Demand Webinar

Fleet leaders confess: Why we switched providers

Duration:

Transcript

Alright.

We got a quorum, but I’m just gonna give everybody a minute to get situated and get in, and then we’ll get started.

Great. Great. I think we’re just gonna get started here now. Just wanna thank everybody for their time, for joining the Fleet Leaders Confess, why we switched providers webinar today. This will be recorded and sent to people via your inbox in the next couple of days. And note that we’re taking q and a live throughout, but they’ll be answered at the end. So my team backstage will handle that, and we will get to them and yield them to the appropriate speaker as they come in.

You don’t have enough time… If we don’t have enough time to get to your questions, we’ll make sure to follow-up. You know, I’ve done a few of these, and lot of questions do come in, and we have people that will be dedicated to answering them after the webinar. So if there’s any one on one support you might need, up in the top right, you’ll see a get started button, and we’ll have somebody follow-up with you shortly after the session.

Again, we appreciate everyone taking their time out of their day, and we’re always inspired by your needs and feedback. So please, please provide any feedback with us today.

My name is Ryan Martin. I’ve been at Motive for a little over two and a half years. I’m a principal value consultant here, and I work with fleets to help understand the strategic and economic benefit of partnering with Motive. I sit in New Hampshire. I really like working with our customers, and I’ll hand it off to the other gentleman here speaking with me today.

Hi there. Good afternoon. Aaron Kelver. I’m with Intercorp Engineered Solutions, based out of Houston, Texas.

We’re a oil and gas service company. Been with the company for over ten years now. Been in this particular role for over six, so it’s been kind of a a big learning curve started in, in COVID, and so that was a lot of fun. Currently, we use, cameras, the telematics, and fuel card from Motive.

My name is Daniel Arnold. I’m the fleet director for TransAl. We’re a family of companies based out of Nashville that operate across, like, 800 vehicles over 23 states providing paratransit, on demand and oh, I drew a blank. And public transit as well. I’ve been with transportation about six years now. Twenty one year career, mainly military and a maintenance background. I am calling in today from Southern Georgia.

Good morning, good afternoon, depending on where you’re located. My name is Clint Ricado. I’m a corporate safety manager at Murphy Hoffman Company Kenworth.

So we are the largest Kenworth dealer in North America calling in from our corporate office in Kansas City, Missouri. My background, I’ve been with MHC for fourteen years, but been in the fleet and safety space since 2003, and we’ve had a partnership with Motive now since 2021, give or take about 1,100, units, and, we also use the Motive fuel card as well.

Yeah. Appreciate you guys’ time today. Just gonna do a couple of quick overview, and then we’ll jump right into the conversation.

So as most known as you guys all know on the call, Motive is the AI powered integrated operating platform for the physical economy. We help companies that keep the physical physical world running operate more safely, productively, and profitably.

Our platform brings together driver safety, fleet management, equipment monitoring, spend management, workforce management, maintenance, and AI vision.

And AI is really the connective tissue across all of it, turning data from the vehicles, equipment, and work sites into decisions that teams can act on.

I really like this slide. I helped work on this one with our team.

Really, it’s just switching providers is one of the decisions that fleet leader…

Fleet leaders put off the longest. Contracts, hardware, retraining, and fear of fear of disruption can make staying with the incumbent feel safer and easier. But every month without a clear business case can delay measurable return. In 2026, Motive ROI report, roughly 351 customers reported reaching various, value more than two x faster after switching from Samsara, almost two x faster from Verizon Connect, and 1.4

x faster from Lytics. Across the report, respondents began seeing ROI in about five months on average, and top respondents reported approximately 1,000,000 in annual savings in fewer accidents. These are survey averages and just not guarantees, we like to disclaim that. Today, these three fleet leaders will put on those benchmarks in real world context.

Daniel on side by side evaluation and utilization, Aaron on measurable safety and incident cost reduction, and Clint on safety culture and manager efficiency. And we’ll cover why they switch from their providers and how they manage the transition and what changed after they switched to Motive.

So I’ll stop sharing, and I’ll jump in to our first poll question. So we’re gonna run a poll here that you’ll see. And, essentially, we’re wondering what provider that you’re currently using.

And then we’ll go into the polls tab, we’ll see who it’s pulling up.

Awesome. And I’ll ask another one too as we go through this. This is just collected for the end here is another one for the group. Caroline, you can pull that one up as well. Is are you thinking about making a switch from your current provider? And then there are literally three prompts there and kind of a so why.

Awesome.

Cool. Thanks. So we have those submitted here. And now let’s jump in, Clint, Aaron, and Daniel.

We’ll go ahead in. Now, you know, we’ve we’ve had this conversation before, but I…

You know, take us back before the switch. What was really breaking down from your previous provider? And then, really, what was the exact tipping point that made you guys say, enough is enough. Really, we…

It’s time to make the switch, and we really want to evolve as a company. We can start with…

I guess we’ll start with Aaron. Go ahead.

Sure. Well, for me, my beginning is a little bit different.

We came from Geotab. We were only using telematics. Right? And so my pitch was like, hey.

Let’s really dive into the cameras, the AI technology. Like, let’s see what it’s all about. We had historically received a lot of pushback from that angle due to privacy concerns. Right?

We’re an oil and gas company. A lot of pushback came from, hey. Dude, our guys are just gonna go elsewhere, and that’s kinda like the the fallacy. Right?

And so I had to really dig deep and understand the different privacy protocols that Motive and others offered and present those to the board to be able to, to get approval to kinda move forward. So, that’s really kind of the the lens I look through is that that privacy. And then also, like, what other information are we gonna be to get by adding the the telematics, the camera, the in cab coaching. Right?

And so a big issue we had upfront is we didn’t have full visibility to our risk profile. Right? We didn’t know what we didn’t know. And so just by adding these cameras, you’re able to really digest and understand what your true risk profile is, and then you’re able to, like, narrow down what you actually need to work on to to make your fleet safe.

Yeah. That’s great. Clint, you wanna you wanna follow-up off that too?

Yeah. So our story is a little bit different here at MHC from Aaron. We had been in the dashcam world essentially since about 2013. So it wasn’t necessarily a hard sell or difficult sell to our executive team or to the field. Really, from our standpoint, coming from Lytex to Motive, we value our vendors at MHC and that loyalty.

And so if we do switch a vendor, it it it has to be for the right reasons. And one of those driving factors there was just the lack of innovation on Lytics’ side.

Like I said, we were pretty established at that point in time, so we were looking for different technologies to push us, just to be safer, to be more efficient. And, when we happen to have… Start the conversations with Motive, their willingness to be creative and really… You guys designed the out of the box vehicle inspection program with the driver app. So between that, the innovations on a… AI development and the bill… The ability to just customize the overall program, it was a no brainer for MHC.

Yeah. That’s awesome. Appreciate that. Go ahead, Daniel. I’ll pass it to you for the… We’ll round it out.

Yeah. So we kinda have a different approach. We had recently signed to renew our contract with Sansera with them promising a lot of additional upgrades and add ons. We… Being in paratransit, we particularly care about our our wheelchair clients where it goes on back there and secure it. Sansera promised that they can get us the visibility in the rear of the vans and the buses, so we renew our contract. We did quite a bit with purchasing additional cables, connectors, cameras, and all these other systems come to find out that they got us a picture, but they didn’t work. So we started initially just kinda testing the field.

We did a a pilot with motor to kinda see how it was because we were very interested in the Omnicam.

And, you know, the Omnicam has been great. It actually gives us visibility inside the vehicle. While we’re doing the pilot, we actually had a pretty significant collision, and it it knocked out both cameras. So we went to Sansera first being our our partner, and they told us it was not… If the video was not on the dashboard, they cannot pull it.

Within forty five minutes of contacting customer service and motive, I I had the video to my inbox. So at at that point, even though we weren’t at a renewal pay… Basis with Sansera, was a no brainer for us to go ahead and make that jump.

Yeah. That’s that’s perfect. I mean, I’ve also been a part of an evaluation where that’s happened too. So it’s it’s really good to hear. Just a quick follow-up and you can… Whoever wants to take it first can. But I guess, what was the biggest business risk created by your old system? I know, Dan, Daniel, you just kind of addressed that a little bit there, but anything else you guys can think of for risk that was on the old system that you wanted to address?

I think from our standpoint at MHC, the limitation from our prior provider, Lytics, was really probably the riskiest piece from our standpoint. We wanna be as proactive as possible. So when we say that we we have a lot of the technology turned on in our trucks and our vehicles, and we just want a full understanding of what that driver’s profile is. So if there is a risk, we can coach it up before it becomes a collision.

Yeah. That’s Yeah. Similarly, for those who are running telematics only like we were, you just have a lack of visibility. You don’t truly understand what your risk profile is. You don’t know who… Which drivers are your worst drivers. And so being able to add that to your calculus and being able to actually see what your risk profile truly is is is huge.

Yeah. It’s big. Ours is kind of along the lines of safety. Like, just like Aaron said, we already had cameras in the vehicle, but actually testing a new a new potential partner and seeing the difference in the safety events and the triggers. That that was very inviting to us.

Yeah. That…

That’s big. I appreciate the the transparency there. Right? It doesn’t go unnoticed, and I’m sure a lot of people are at that point where it’s, hey.

What are we doing? What do we wanna do next? And how do we go there? So, you know, that brings us obviously to the next question, and I I know you guys have a lot to say on this one.

But it’s how are you comparing providers fairly? You know, what was the process that you went through for evaluating each vendor, and how did you score them? I know we did a side by side through one of them, but just happy to hear your thoughts on these.

Sure. I guess for us, at Intercorp, you know, we ran a small trial. We’re about 240 vehicles at the time. We took 10 trucks, installed the motive. We also did a side by side with Samsara.

And so we were really looking at, originally, just like, hey. What does the the triggering look like? What’s the AI accuracy look like? And I put them in my personal truck actually since I’m the one kind of heading up this whole program.

I I put it in my personal vehicle so I could really attest and talk to these systems. And I noticed right away that the the Motive system, the AI was definitely superior. It had a lot more detections, especially when you’re talking about cell phones.

And the nice part is is even through that three month trial that we did, they were continuously rolling out updates and new detections and things like that. Their their road map is really good. So, being able to see their road map, compared to Samsara’s, which they just didn’t have much on it. You know, that was two years ago, so I don’t I don’t know what that looks like now.

But really, really can’t talk enough about Motiv’s road map and just how transparent they are about what they’re working on. So really, really enjoyed that that piece of it. But you really just broke down, like, what’s important to you, you know, cell phone violations, close following, and dial in those settings as equal as possible, and let’s see what the detection does. So that’s kinda how we played it.

Awesome. Appreciate it. No more texting and driving, Aaron. You know? We’ll catch you. That’s right.

I would I would say from Aaron’s point that I would encourage everybody, on the webinar, if you haven’t put one in your personal vehicle, it really helps with just talking points during the rollout to speak to the technology and how it works.

So we did that in our safety department as well before we did our side by side, and and we selected our Joplin dealership. And we did a side by side with Motive and Lytics and really kinda did a like for like same behaviors even though there wasn’t as many AI triggers with Lytics we did with Motive.

But we also knew that we’re gonna have a little more frequency with Motive, and we were we were fine with that because the more that that information we can gather allowed us to be proactive, allowed us to stay true to our mission statement and getting folks home safe and sound each and every night.

So that’s kind of the comparison that we did here at MHC.

Yeah. Appreciate that. I’m a data nerd, so the more info, the better for me. So go ahead, Daniel.

So we didn’t wanna commit without knowing that we were gonna get a ROI.

So we tested four different companies. And each one we tested, we tested them in different vehicles alongside our Sansera cameras. We took our Sansera’s… Our settings and sent those to the competitors. So everything was as equal as it could be. And the thirty day trial, we noticed that Motive had 17 times, picked up on cell phone violations over what Samsara was, was notifying us on.

Yeah. That…

It’s…

That’s incredibly transparent. And then, obviously, you know, when you do side by sides and you compare, I have to ask the follow-up. So it’s all things equal. You know, how is it measured, and how do you keep the comparisons even?

So if somebody’s to go through this process and they wanna have the settings to make sure that they are doing it accurately aside from the personal vehicles. Right? How are you measuring that compared to whoever wants to yield that one?

So we ran them side by side, directly into the mirror. So there’s there’s no variance that, you know, one’s looking up, one’s looking down. We’ve aired the program, all of our settings and all of our thresholds, and then we just ran it thirty days. Pulled the dashboard at the end of the thirty days, and they did a complete analysis and comparison.

Yep. Appreciate that. Super helpful. And then, Aaron, I know you you brought it into your personal vehicle. Were you running side by side there as well and then across, obviously, your trial fleet?

So Yeah.

Yep. Yeah. And I still actually have the Motive camera in my personal vehicle just for if someone calls up and says, hey. Your threshold for x y z is too stringent. I’ve I’ve got it in my truck, I can test it out and make sure there’s no issues. But on on top of that, it just… I mean, it makes you a better driver. Just… There’s no two ways about it.

Yeah. For sure. And then, Clint, I know you did the side by side, but I think it’s worth asking to say to make sure were settings equal? Was everything set the same in terms of sensitivity analysis? So when you’re capturing, it was fair?

Yeah. The the only thing that I would say, we wanted to test… Everything was thresholds were equal. Behaviors were were equal, but we want to see how that, the in alert… In cab alert played out as well, just to see… We wanted that feedback from our drivers.

And, well, I’m sure we’ll talk more about that, but, that was the only difference. But, our drivers love that because it gave them an opportunity to be accountable for their actions, essentially.

I turned it on to my personal vehicle. I’m much better at rolling stocks now.

Listen. I’m from the Northeast, so it happens all the time up here. Yeah. We’re just gonna throw a quick poll out. I’ll let, the team handle it. But what outcome would create the strongest business case for for switching providers? And you can answer the poll as it pops up, and we’ll we’ll gather the data and address it in the chat.

And then I’ll go back to you guys. We’ll go back into the the conversation here as that poll is being answered. But, you know, our research shows that many fleet dealers or many fleets defer switching because, obviously, it’s a longer time to value. You know, what do you measure first and what measurable value did Motive hit within your first year? And then kinda which result changed how you operated or made those investment decisions as it related to, you know, to making that switch?

Well, for us, we got a pretty quick ROI out of it. I think it was thirteen months. And so we reduced our incident rate over 60% in the first year.

We were… The year the year prior of rollout, we had about $450,000 worth of vehicle incidents. Year to date, this year, 65 k.

And so you see just a dramatic decrease in not only cost of incidents, but severity of incidents. We haven’t had any total vehicles this year. We haven’t had any injuries in in in those incidents.

So a reduction of the severity, I mean, is huge, right, not just in your cost and liability, but just you want your people to be safe.

And and it has just a 100% proven that it that it has done that.

So for us being a smaller company, 400 k may be peanuts to you guys, but when you’re talking percentages, that’s a huge percentage drop, in in your cost. So, it really really worked out for us.

Yeah. And you you lessened your your risk profile as well by the cell phone reduction. I think it was… Well, I can’t remember the exact percentage.

78% in cell phone reduction, violations.

So, again, it’s one of those things. The first few months when you implement it, you’re gaining…

Well, for us, we didn’t have, cameras before. We’re understanding that first quarter is, okay. What are our guys doing naturally? And now where do we need to focus our training on to reduce these different categories?

And so, yeah, we let it run the first quarter, let everybody know that, hey. No one’s getting deemed the first quarter. This is just you understanding how the system works. And then once that first quarter of implementation’s over, now you guys are held accountable for what’s going on.

And and Clint mentioned before the thresholds being able to self correct.

That was important for us is kind of keeping the burden off of our supervisors and putting it directly back on to the driver. So we have whatever threshold it is. They get an in cab alert, and they get x amount of seconds to correct that behavior. If they do so, it’s between them and the camera.

The the supervisor doesn’t have to get involved. And so that’s worked out quite a bit. And then you know if someone does need a conversation that’s actually warranted because they weren’t paying attention to the safety system. Right?

Yeah. I mean, that’s perfect. And, also, 400 k is not peanuts. I’m not sure who who thinks it might be, but that allow…

You know, that allows the free cash flow to go back to the business to strategically set up.

Our company was certainly very ecstatic over it. So, yeah, it worked out great.

Yeah. Perfect. And, Clint, I guess I’ll tee you up since Aaron kinda leaned on you there.

Yeah. So keep in mind, you know, when we did the transition, we were well into, you know, kind of seeing the the big bump when you just put the cameras in back in 2013. So… But we saw over that ten year span with Lytics is how a dashcam and that safety program can can really bleed over that we wanna see. And when I say bleed over, it’s into our driver’s personal lives that we would get feedback from our drivers from the standpoint of, hey. When I’m driving around with my family now, it… It’s coached me so much in my work vehicle that now I’m a better driver with my family. So we measure that, and we take that in as far as, you know, that’s very important, from the switchover, but, also, we measure culture from the standpoint of it’s not an accident that MHC, in twenty twenty twenty three, we achieved our best injury rate, historically with the company. And we feel that from a safety culture standpoint, Motive and the dashcam program really helped us from that too.

Yeah. That’s that’s super helpful. Appreciate that. And then, Daniel?

So, one of the key things with Motive is the the driver’s app, which for us significantly decreased the it hit the coaching time, which is imperative just like the other gentleman we’re talking about. But the main way we’ve seen a a major ROI was we went into analytics and started looking at our our vehicle utilization rates. Everybody breaches it. You know, they’re they’re the most efficient. And looking at the data, we started pulling vehicles that were underutilized. We were able to repurpose 90 vehicles after about the first four months of actually having the load systems in our vehicle.

Yeah. That’s… I think it’s it’s always interesting to know what you don’t know after the fact, and getting that data is is incredibly helpful. So I appreciate that. And then, Aaron, you kinda leaned on this a little bit, but it tees me up to my next question, right, about the accountability pieces. You know, how do you explain the why with the privacy, the accountability, and the driver benefit? You know? And, really, after that, what changed for the rollout, you know, for the team?

Yeah. We definitely… We built a a pretty organized rollout and communication with our people because I think, especially for us not having cameras to to begin with, this is kind of new for everyone.

Really important that everybody understands why we’re doing it. Right? And we do have a great safety culture, and we we kind of always have, and that’s what we leaned on is, like, we truly want you to go home the way you came. And this isn’t about listening to your conversations or watching you while you eat.

You know, there’s a lot of settings. So we we discuss those privacy settings where, hey, in cab audio, it’s off. I can’t hear what you’re saying. I don’t need to hear what you’re saying.

When the vehicle isn’t in motion, the camera turns off. The inside camera turns off. I don’t need to see you eating. Like, this is purely designed to reduce your your risk profile and make you a better better driver.

Right? And so when we really kind of talk through those pieces and then also under…

Had them understand, like, you can self correct and no one even sees that you did this. Like, everyone kinda took a step back, took a breath, and was like, oh, okay. Like, if if I just listen to what it’s telling me to do, then everything’s gonna be fine.

There… There’s only a couple things that we have zero tolerance on. One of them is, like, seat belts. Right? Like, there’s just zero tolerance. Seat belts, there’s no excuse for you to not wear your seat belt.

So that…

That’s kind of how we how we looked at that. And employees really went from digging their heels in the ground to understanding that, oh, man. This really isn’t that bad. Another thing we did was is we took kind of the field supervisors, like the leaders of the different groups that are in the field, and we had them install it in their trucks first and run it for a month.

And so they could directly talk to their employees and and give their experience of, hey. This is what it is. This is what it isn’t. They’re they’re not blowing smoke.

Like, this this program is gonna work out for you. So that’s kinda how we approach that.

Yeah. I appreciate that. I I wanted to give you props there. I think the educational program leading up to it is one of the ones that I have to tip my cap.

I think it matters, and it helps with that change management component. So, you know, thanks for that. Thanks for sharing that. Sure.

Daniel, I’ll kick it to you.

So for us, the drivers already had a camera, but adding one to the rear of the vehicle, they were pretty hesitant. Just essentially, you know, just like Eric said, people are trying to look in arms, see what’s going on.

We did, training management, the kind of coach teach mentor, mindset with it, top down communication, effectively communicate exactly what the the camera were there to do, the purpose of it. And then we asked them for about sixty to ninety days just to kinda follow with us at ninety days. If it didn’t work, we would look at taking it out. After about the third or fourth wheelchair complaint came in, and we called the driver in the office and pulled up the video and said, hey.

Look. This is this is exactly what you did. You’re right. It’s not the the driver’s word versus the client’s word.

We actually had video surveillance. And that was about day 45 to 60. We had a couple of those, and then there’s some word-of-mouth from the drivers. They bought it.

They got to the point that the last few vehicles that were trickling in, they would actually call their managers. Hey. When can I get my vehicle to the shop to get these cameras in? Because I I really wanna camera my bus like everybody.

Yeah. Yeah. And and it’s always nice to see the safety program emphasize the positive. Right? Everything has to be the negative, and I think that tees it up nicely for for Clint and how he rolled things out as well.

Yeah. I mentioned it before that, just the customizing of the program to kinda dial it in to where we were at that point in time, but we also have a recognition program. And, again, the in cab alerts, our our folks loved it just because it allows them to self correct before it turns into an actual video capture.

Now, like Aaron, and Daniel said, we do have some kind of hard lines, distraction, distracted driving, seat belts. There… There’s things that they really don’t get an in cab alert, but everything else, we give our our drivers the opportunity to coach themselves, hold themselves accountable, and correct it before it turns into a coachable event.

Yeah. Appreciate that. I mean, the theme there is it seems self correction meets the safety, meets emphasis on the positive there. So that’s a it’s a good trend.

Shouldn’t kinda change directions a little bit here, but, you know, according to g two’s fall reports, Motive customers reported going live at about 30% faster time than Samsara customers, roughly 40% faster than Linux customers. You know, implementation is often often the biggest risk. Right? Obviously, you worry about it when you switch.

There’s that change management components…

Component. Can you take us inside the rollout? And outside of preparing the people in the coaching programs, talk about the install, and then how long did it take to reach that adoption? And, really, are there anything else that you’d wanna touch on as it re…

Relates to that installation process?

Sure. Yeah. With that intercorporate, it was actually pretty smooth. I was I was impressed with the process.

They did some good upfront training, and doc had good documentation of how to do it. So I’m only based…

I have me and and my DOT manager, and that’s…

That…

That’s us. So him and I went out to our different regions, during the week of kickoff, and, we have got a mechanic in in each location. So we just…

We went to each location. We stayed there for a couple days and helped it to kickoff, get as many of those installed in those couple of days with us there as we could. And then we did the same thing the last week of implementation. We went out and rounded up all the stragglers and and got them accomplished.

But, basically, just me, my DOT manager on the front end, and then one guy in each location, we’re able to do 240 in three months.

We did it all in house. I mean, it’s OBD two port, so it’s super easy to do a self install, at least on the half ton trucks that that we’re running mostly. So, yeah, for us, it was a really smooth process. And you guys helped with some of our 18 wheelers. We needed some third party install with some OmniCams and things like that. But you guys lined it out for us. So, I mean, no hiccups or headaches there.

Awesome. Appreciate that.

Clint, you wanna Yeah.

So our rollout, we we approached it very similar to how we rolled out Lytics as well, where we did not install, one dashcam before we got in front of all of our locations.

So it it it was the team effort of… Basically, we’re decentralized locations, about a 130 throughout the Midwest and the South, and, no one drove with a camera in their vehicle until they got the onboarding. The onboarding kinda explained the why and then… But also the installation. If you recall, back in the day, Lytex had a three wire install, so not everybody could install, the camera, and the hardware.

It was more of… We have in house technicians as well, so those kinda had to be scheduled out a little bit longer process. Within the rollout, we kinda explained, hey. This is a plug and play. This is how you do it. So it’s very seamless, and that was part of the why and the sell to our executive team that, hey. Basically, our outside salesman, our mobile techs, our delivery drivers can install these in pretty quick fashion, and it and it was very helpful from that standpoint.

Yeah. That’s super informative. Thank you. Go ahead, Daniel.

So we kinda did a dual approach because we already had cameras in the vehicles.

Just like Clint and Aaron said, it’s very easy to install. We actually had some of our lead drivers at some of our remote locations doing some of their install.

But as we installed them, we took the the pilot that we initially did, and that’s where all of our training videos came from. So when we kinda briefed to our… All of our drivers what was going on, we were… We did not use the vendor pitch. We used everything from in house so they could see exactly how how it was affecting our own organization. And then we use the feedback of the drivers that tested it provided, along with a lot of input from Motive. Motive gave us a a ton of resources when it come to training. They actually have the resources and actually built a micro training site specifically for our organization with all of our organization logos.

Sorry. And then, they actually built up a different slide deck that actually helped us track completion with every one of the either webinar, the prerecorded webinars, or the training slides that we had we had predetermined for each level of management. They actually tracked us and helped us get to 95% completion before they kind of moved us over to our our current account managers.

Yeah. That’s that’s crazy. 95%. We got a question from the audience, and it kinda tees up a little bit of a follow-up.

You’ve all briefly touched on it. Right? And the first part before the subsequent parts is obviously the material difference. Right?

I know it’s sometimes hard to think about a previous life before motive, but if you can go back and think about installing then, what was material…

Materially different then to now? And then as you go through all the last two trickle down follow ups after that.

So if you’re with Sansera if you’re with Sansera, it’s very similar to Sansera. It’s just the OBD two port, the pigtail, and the gateway.

If you get into the OmniCamera, the OmniCamera is slightly different, but not overly cumbersome.

Okay. Thanks. Clint, did you come off… Did you wanna jump in or no?

Yeah. I I would say, you know, from the older Lytex hardware, as as I mentioned earlier, the three wire install, that was quite some time. But they also transitioned from a plug and play, but very seamless. And I I would say, you know, installation time wise, I mean, you’re probably talking at most twenty minutes.

Awesome. That’s that’s how we did it. When we when we lined them up, we’d get five trucks beside each other and bam bam bam bam. It’s, you know, fifteen minutes in install.

Super super quick.

Awesome. Yeah. And that you partially addressed the first part of the question. It said how long is the lead time on installers for initial installation per fifteen, twenty minutes roughly? And then the second time is how long is the lead time for installers for repairs on existing systems?

Well, that one… So we’ve… The the industry has kind of shrunk a little bit this year for us in oil and gas over the last two years. And so we’ve actually had spare units on the shelf.

So I I couldn’t really answer that question because we’ll just… If we have a problem, which we’ve only had one or two, we’ll just swap the camera and send it in. I haven’t really been tracking the time on that. We haven’t had an immediate need for it. So I I don’t know if Clint or Daniel has a better response, but, yeah, I I couldn’t answer that honestly.

So we’ve had one we’ve had to exchange, because was because of an accident. But once I reached out to my account manager, told him what was going on, I had the the label the next day, and he asked us if we wanted to replace it or just send it back. If we wanted to replace it, he was gonna ship it out the same day. If not that day, the next day.

So lead time, maybe maybe seventy two hours, I would say.

Yep.

I would I would agree with Daniel on that. The RMA process is pretty seamless, and pretty user friendly from that standpoint. But, also, like Aaron, when our trucks are down, that’s money. So we do have some spares where we will send those out and swap out the hardware while we’re waiting on the r… RMA process. So the less down… Downtime from that standpoint, the better from most companies, I would imagine.

Yeah. Yep. So zero minutes. No.

It’s just Right.

We’ll, we’ll hop to the next question here. But, you know, it’s kind of in the same one, the zero to downtime. Right? You want the you want the vehicles on the road. You want you want your fleet being out there and servicing and doing what it’s intended. So where are you seeing the clearest operational value and the, the clearest financial value Is it safety utilization, fuel, data visibility? What might it be?

I would say… Go ahead, Dan.

I would say from our end, it would be the fleet utilization, kinda comparing the safety now to just the in-depth fleet tracking and the reports that you can run, but also tailoring that with… We’re on the Motive fuel card now. So just seeing your miles per per gallon performance from your vehicles. But also from our standpoint, it used to be that, hey. We hired a new delivery driver, and it was just always the thought process of we gotta get a new parts vehicle. Now we have the capability of looking at idling downtime utilization where we can… Instead of purchasing a new asset, we can repurpose that vehicle to another location, which helps us be more efficient across the board. So that’s where we’ve seen an operational, financial benefit from that standpoint.

Yeah. That’s helpful.

I have to second that. We… We’ve just started on the motive fuel card a couple of months ago. So we haven’t… I don’t have a number to the financial impact on it yet, but I can say coming from WEX through home and our FMC, that were our previous provider, there’s just so much more granular detail that we get with the motive card, so much more information than than any other card we’ve had. So you can really… And there’s a nice little savings calculator on there to understand, like, hey, where missed opportunities were so you can have conversations with those drivers to be able to save more money in the future, get better rebates.

And then you can reward your drivers who are doing a great job, who are idling less, who are going to the cheapest fuel stations nearby, those kinds of things. So that paired with your GPS on the truck and the GPS of the terminal in which you’re swiping the card, that additional layer of security is really nice, that I haven’t seen, like, from WEX or cards like that. So, y’all pairing up those extra security features has been really nice.

Lastly, we do have some traveling guys. Guys will do some over the road driving. And so they don’t have a company credit card, but they do have a motor fuel card. And so when they’re out of town, we can say, hey.

We’re gonna unlock spend to go get a hotel and get dinner. And so we can unlock it for three days or whatever we need it to be. And then we don’t have to remember to go back and turn it off or whatever else. You can just set your parameters and forget about it.

So a lot of flexibility and and information and data in the fuel card, which I find very valuable.

Yep. That’s helpful, especially with your reduced safety cost too as well. I know that you touched on that earlier, but that’s a nice a nice bow tie. Go ahead, Daniel. Sorry. I didn’t mean to cut you off there.

No. You’re good, Ryan. So we’ve been with the the motive card for fuel for about a year, and we’ve been exploring different features. Like, Aaron, we came from WEX, and we run a lot of rural transportation. So a lot of the mom and pop gas stations.

We knew we had some fuel theft going on, but we didn’t know how much. We would usually catch it a month later when we received our invoice. So going to Motive and all the different, savings and, security features that they have, we did an analysis. We went from essentially 30 to 30% fuel theft and misuse down to about two percent.

With that and with using the savings finder, which Aaron was talking about, you can log in and show show you where all of your cheapest fuel is along your route. We’ve been using that and putting a lot more emphasis on that. We’re roughly about nine to 10% under what the national average is for fuel right now, which is actually really good considering we’re in 23 different states. So it’s not that we’re in the cheapest area, so it’s just a benefit. So that alone is actually a lifesaver when it comes to the amount of money, especially how, costly fuel is right now.

Yeah. You’re not lying.

If I could jump in real quick. One of the…

You know, just wanna reiterate reiterate, we also were a, WEX, on the WEX program as well. And the problem there is that the crime is already committed at that point in time where there are checks and balances with the motive card that allows you to prevent the crime from even happening. So the money is not lost from that standpoint. But another operational and financial thing that we are looking at as well is the the idling piece and setting out alerts, you know, now that Motiv has converted from more of a coaching to more of a performance platform that kinda encompasses idling and how our drivers are using their vehicles from that standpoint as well.

So we’re excited to look at that and turn that feature as on because we think there’s some opportunity there. I would also say we’re trialing the AI coach as well and…

In one of our regions, and where we see the opportunity there is to give some time back to our management, and coaching up, our drivers because we can manage that workflow to where the AI coach can handle some of that lighter lifting, heavier lifting as well. So, those are some of the other things we’re looking at.

Yeah. I appreciate that. That’s… I mean, that’s… I just… I always think it’s interesting to see what what the evaluation goes through, but it also sounds like with the motive card and being able to see the data, we’re seeing operational efficiencies gained. Right? It makes your life easier as it comes to that data, right, with that being in centralized location. So, yeah, I just wanted to put a little note on that.

And then before we switch over to the to the q and a here, I got one more question for for all three of you here, and it’s… You know, many leaders are currently finalizing their budgets for 2027. Right? And they’re running into contract expirations and then switching costs. So if you were in their shoes, you know, what’s… What would be a decision as to why this is the right moment to make the change? And then what advice would you give to somebody who might be a little hesitant as to why it makes sense to make the shift?

Well, I’d… I’ll take that one to start if you don’t mind. But Yeah.

No problem.

What’s what’s your opportunity cost?

What’s your risk profile? And if you were like us and you didn’t even understand what your risk was, you know, you had potential liabilities out there for wrecks. Because, I mean, when you’re a business and you have your business name on the side of your vehicle, you’re a target. I mean, we just got a demand letter the other day for a fender bender, and everybody goes to litigation when you have a company name on the side of your vehicle.

So what is your opportunity cost for not making a switch, for not implementing state of the art AI technology and cameras? Right? So I I think that’s what you have to ask yourself. And if you are switching from another provider of of similar services, I think it’s worth your time to do a side by side trial and and understand what you’re missing out on.

Yeah. I I would say in our climate right now and, you know, some some of my safety friends in the past have talked about, well, I don’t want video because it’s discoverable. But, really, in our climate of nuclear verdict… Verdicts, you can’t really afford that anymore. I mean, you you need that insight, that visibility because you need that proactiveness to prevent the collision from happening.

Yeah. That’s that’s so true. And, Daniel, you round it off.

Yeah. So in in terms of what Erin and what Clint said, when you have your company logo on the side of your vehicle, you’re a target. Whether you want the video or not, you need the video. If you’re at fault, you’re at fault. But if you’re not at fault, if it’s your word against somebody else’s, you’re gonna come out of pocket just to appease the other person. So it’s imperative that you can prove that you did not you did not perform any crime. For TransAl, we actually…

We we we resigned with, Sansera, and we were gonna keep another three year contract. And then we ended up leaving and buying out our contract midterm just based on the customer service and the lack of data that you have crossed.

Like Aaron said, it… It’s very, very much effective to do a side by side. We did our side by side trial. And as soon as we presented that to our CEO, he’s like, alright. Where do I sign? When do we switch? We have to protect our assets.

Yep. Right. And it’s it’s always interesting when you make the switch to see the financial savings, the operational effectiveness take place. So, yeah, I appreciate all the time and the questions that we have on this end.

I’m gonna dig into the audience q and a. So, Daniel, it’s nice you you teed it up perfectly there at the end, right, when it comes to Samsara and getting out of the contract. But you guys are always one step ahead of me right now, it seems like. But this is for Daniel specifically, but anybody else can chime in with the support side of stuff.

How does the support team here compare to Samsara? Right? And then did you see any decrease with false positives or false negatives by switching to Motive?

Yes. I’ve seen a ton of false positives and negatives when we swap the Motive. I mean, you’re always gonna have your outliers, but at the same time, Motive is very much user friendly. You can go in and tweak. I go to work… Our account manager all the time and ask them to help tweak settings.

The support…

The support’s been second to none. I reached out to my account manager at 08:05 this morning. So, hey. We had answered that.

I didn’t get a notification. Can you can you get a hold of the engineer team? By 09:30, he come back and said, hey. Some…

Somebody turned off this setting. But that’s the level of of, support that I expect. You know, we’re we’re putting you money. We’re getting these products.

That’s that’s the level of, product support that I expect when it comes to these, especially dealing with safety and a lot of the good of our vehicles.

Yeah. I appreciate that. That’s that’s really transparent and honest. And I I know our AMs work hard here, so a shout out to them as well. Aaron and Clint, you’re more than welcome to chime in on the support side too.

Well, I’ll give you my experience from… Like, we had a sales team, implementation team, post sales. Each part of the process… And I I just… Honestly, the true feedback was just phenomenal. And I’ve been through multiple software implementations where it’s not.

But they really do have a great sales team, implementation team. I just had a white glove service. I really felt that truly a white glove service, all the way through the process. So I couldn’t be happier with with how it all turned out. You know, we got a great team.

Yeah. I I would say that the difference is, with our prior, provider, really, the account manager was kinda managing everything, anything from updates, program reviews, hardware, the technical piece of it to where I feel that Motive gives you layers of support. So our account manager, she’s a rock star. She’s always available. I can text her at any time, but she’s kind of the manager of different different needs that we have. So we have somebody assigned to overall the technical questions, and we’ll have a call. If we wanna call weekly, Ours are biweekly, and and we touch on everything from updates to reporting, from technical issues, if we have any at all.

You know? So the support is…

It’s rock solid.

Thank you. Appreciate that. And it seems that a lot of people are curious. Are any of you using maintenance evaluating the maintenance platform with Motive today?

Yes. Like I said, my my background is mainly maintenance. So maintenance and logistics is one thing I really care about. We have, implemented all of our preventative maintenance, our, our engine faults, our daily vehicle inspections.

Every bit of that runs through Motive. I pulled it out. I’ve created my own dashboard using SPAD, but it updates every morning, tells me every, every minor defect, every major defect, every engine fault code, and every status of any oil change that I have that’s either upcoming past due or has been complete. And it…

It’s been phenomenal.

Yeah. We do similar. We don’t use the full functionality of it, but the, the fault codes is huge for us to be able to make a determination of, hey. Does this guy need to get to a shop right now, or can this wait?

And so we’re always looking at that at live data as as much as possible. And we did similar to you. We’ve built a kind of our own cloud dashboard page that gives us, you know, instant alerts to see exactly what we wanna see. But, yeah, fault codes are great.

That’s something we use…

Utilize all the time.

Yeah. And there’s a there’s a spend savings behind that as… Again, I I love that side of the the program and the platform. So that’s super helpful. And then I’m just gonna lean into a reliability one, answering the questions as I see them come in. What is cold weather and hot weather reliability of the units that you’re using? How is it, and is there anything that you’d change?

The only thing I’ve noticed here in Houston, Texas, I’ve got… I’m trialing one of the new, AI dash cam plus units. During the dead heat of the summer, it can have a… It can take a little time to cool off before it’ll kick on. Right? So you’ll hear the fan going, and it needs to cool off when it’s been sitting in a 140, 50 degree truck.

That’s that’s all that I’ve noticed, though. I’ve… It’s never really given me an issue of actually functioning. It just may need a few minutes to cool off before it kicks on.

No. I haven’t witnessed anything in terms of hot or cold. I know if the vehicle goes to the shop for, an extended period of time, sometimes that it needs to be reset, once it comes back out of the shop, but I haven’t seen any any factors of hot or cold.

I would say from a cold standpoint, some are more northern locations that prior provider, we had a lot of dead batteries, a lot of pull off those batteries where we are not experienced that with Motive one bit. So it’s been a pleasant surprise from that standpoint.

Awesome. I’ll do kind of a well… Or well rounded one here, just overarching theme. Right? And we… The continued underlying theme I hear is the data, the access to visibility, the access to what’s happening within the business and making those decisions. You know, outside of the safety program, operationally, think day to day, what’s really the biggest change that you’ve seen with people using the system, and how are those changes taking place internally for you guys?

I would say that we’re starting to transition, to more of…

We used… We’re a very exception based company.

So we’ve managed the program in the past and the hardware that when something does happen, go out and go into the system and address it.

And we’re starting to transition to now go to your dashboard every day, one of your first to dos in the morning just because it’s not just about safety. It’s performance now. It’s fuel. So, really, it’s gonna be more of just an operational report, an operational dashboard to see how efficient you are. So we’re transitioning kinda more of that exception base where only going in when you’ve gotta address something now. It’s like there’s information out there that you need to look at at a daily basis.

Yeah. We’re actually starting to use that safety profile data for promotion determination. Right? We’re we’re a safety forward company.

And if you want to move up within the ranks, like, we’re not gonna promote someone who has a horrible safety culture, right, and and isn’t playing by the rules. It’s one of our core values, caring. Right? You gotta pay attention.

You gotta care about what you’re doing, and that includes the the safety aspect. So we’ve been able to kind of incorporate that into just an integral pillar of promotions.

So we have a safety incentive program and in swapping your motive, and everything is at the driver’s fingertips with their app. They can see their events near real time.

They can coach themselves, and that’s really put a lot of onus on the drivers and a lot of accountability. Now if they see something, hey. This happened. Let me explain to my manager what’s going on and be extenuating behind it and see, you know, if it’s gonna get this missed or if it actually stands or even if they get positive points for it.

So that’s actually changed a lot of our culture. And then we… We’ve taken it one step forward. We just actually submitted and went to the workforce management, which integrates AI coaching, the automatic training. So, like, some people with the the cell phone violation, if they get triggered for a cell phone violation, it automatically sends them additional training that they have, you know, a predetermined amount of time to complete.

So that… And, also, at the end of the week with the AI coach, they get a recap of their week. They tell them, you know, how they did in terms of safety, performance.

Ours, we have a lot of idling for client loading and unloading procedures. So it tells them over that week how long they… That vehicle is idled and how much fuel and how that equates to a dollar amount of what they waste for that vehicle. So that’s kind of where we’re going with the next steps of it.

Yeah. That’s… Again, Daniel, being ahead of me one step every time here, one of the questions that came in was, how do you, you know, how do you ensure that the drivers are actually watching the coaching videos? And then how do you make sure they’re working outside of safety score?

I can go from here and to… We gave them five. We tied it to an incentive based program. They get a monetary… Depending on their score and, you know, their quite… The critical events, they get a monetary value back to them at the end of each month.

And we can go in. They have a new feature in Motive where you can see, their coaching score, how well they’ve coached. Now they have a coaching score for the coaches. So you can see how well your coaches are actually coaching their drivers. Just like Clint said, you go in each morning, kinda check those metrics, and then you can kinda get that that preventative approach before you have to get a reactive approach and catch some of that before it becomes a major safety issue.

Yeah. We we monitor that as well, monitor the coaching.

We…

We’re all big on documentation. Right? That’s one of the big benefits of the program is when you do a a coaching session with your supervisor, you have all the documentation. Here’s the video clips.

Here’s when it happened, and then they type notes of their conversation. Right? They sign it at the end. Now you have a document that says, hey.

This person was coached. It was one on one.

You know? And then you can kind of keep track of those and if they’re repeat offenders or not, and then, you know, how well that coach is doing. So, yeah, it’s it’s important to kind of make sure that your processes are being followed and your coaches are having meaningful conversations they should have. But it’s flexible.

Right? If you trust your people, you don’t need a bunch of written statements. You know, they can just sign off on the document, but we like to have a paper trail. Right?

So document as best you can. So when we have those conversations, we we document them.

Yeah. When when you’re… You know, I know the question is, hey. How do you validate if somebody’s viewed their video?

What’s cool about the feature and coaching, you can you can see if they actually have because it stamps it right there. But one of the reasons why we’re looking at the AI coach is just the opportunity, the reporting on the back end that they’ve viewed their summary, their weekly summary, and you can report on that as well. So I think that’ll be a benefit for us as well.

Yeah. Yeah. Super helpful. Super thankful for the responses. I got one more, and then I can let you guys go. But a a question came in that asked if you guys are using any of the asset tracking side of stuff. I know we talked about utilization, but people are curious, you know, how does it work and how is it helpful for the business?

Yeah. So it’s something I’m interested in because I’m also the asset manager. I manage all of our dumb equipment. So we do have the the asset trackers that are powered for some of our 18 wheeler trailers and and things like that.

And then for our remote off-site, off grid stuff, we use the beacon. And currently, it’s in trial phase because we’re o n g. Right? A lot of our stuff needs to be c one d two certified, And I know Motive is kind of working through that.

But our stuff that can be further away from the wellhead, we use the we use the the beacon. And we really enjoy it because our trucks are kind of always going around those job sites. And the way it works is it’s not a g…

The beacon isn’t a GPS. It’s a mesh system. So, like, it it basically Bluetooth pings off of your vehicle gateway. And so when a vehicle gets within a 100 feet or so, it’ll ping it, and it’ll show you the last location.

And so for your your assets that you need less granular visibility on just to understand generally where the things are, it works very well. For your expensive, more important things that you need to be able to know exactly where it is at any point in time and hit a button and get a direct ping, that’s gonna be your your asset gateway, your powered asset gateway. So, they got some flexibility there, but I’ve been impressed with it. Cost is great on the beacons, so, I would recommend them.

Thanks, Aaron. And then Daniel or Clint?

We’re currently not running any of the asset side of it.

Every one of our vehicles is power generation, so everything is gateway.

Cool. Well, Aaron, I appreciate that answer. You know, it came in from the audience, so it’s definitely helpful for them. I know we have four minutes left, but, I’ll use one last question. This is gonna be for you, Aaron. Is it Beacon that you’re using?

Yeah. We we do have a couple of, asset gateways, but Beacon mostly. Yes.

Yeah. And then somebody is curious, obviously, Beacon, can it be used to capture hours for the asset that you’re tracking, or you like to do it that way?

No. I I think you have to have the asset gateway to be able to capture, like, engine hours and run time, things like that. I don’t think the beacon has that capability.

K. Cool. Yeah. And that’s that’s really all I had from the audience and really all I had for you guys on my end as well.

But I am grateful as always for your time. I could quite literally talk to all of you for probably five days, six days, and just love to understand how you’re how you’re running your day to day operations and how you’re seeing the savings. So thank you all so much for your time today. I know we have…

We’re at the top of the hour, basically, but I…

It’s…

It doesn’t go unnoticed having these conversations, and I know it takes time and effort as it goes in here. So so…

But thank you all three of you very much. It’s greatly appreciated. And then to everybody else who is attending, there will be a recording, and it’ll be followed up and sent out to everybody after this within a day. And then if anybody would like to learn more or follow-up questions, there’s the blue get started button at the top.

So feel free to click that, and we’ll have somebody from the motive side follow-up with you. And if you ever see Clint, Aaron, or Daniel in person, try not to interrogate them too much. I feel like they’ve been through the heat here a little bit. But, again, appreciate all of your time, and thank you to everybody virtually for attending.

Absolutely. Thanks for your time.

Thank you guys so much.

Thanks, everybody.

Expand transcript

Webinar details

Switching fleet management providers feels like a hassle, so plenty of organizations keep putting it off. In this live panel, three fleet leaders share why they made the move.

Hear what made them walk away from their old provider, how they compared options, and what changed for drivers, managers, and the bottom line after they chose Motive.

Real stories, honest advice, and live Q&A with peers who’ve been through it. Wondering if it’s time to consider a change? Start here.

We’ll cover:

  • Meet the fleets: three leaders, three industries, and the goals that shaped their programs.
  • The breaking point: why the old way stopped working and what made switching worth it.
  • How to evaluate fairly: what mattered most to them and what set providers apart.
  • The payoff: why they chose Motive and how they’re getting more value today.

Meet our speakers

speaker image

Ryan Martin

Principal Value Consultant, Motive

LinkedIn icon
speaker image

Aaron Kelver

Asset & Fleet Manager, EnerCorp

LinkedIn icon
speaker image

Clint Brocato

Corporate Safety Manager, Murphy-Hoffman Company

LinkedIn icon
speaker image

Daniel Arnold

Fleet Director, TranSouth

LinkedIn icon